Re: Over unity generators - getting interesting

[Victor Tikhonov <vtikhono@lsil.com>]

Doug Littlefield wrote:
> 
> Victor:
> 
> In essence we have a device that uses motion to generate static electricity
> that is
> then amplified and converted to useful electricity. period, end of story.

> It is
> larger than a softball and smaller than a football ... little room for
> trickery there.
> 
> No magic, certainly not perpetual motion, no genie in the box...
> 
> After the drive people with the capability to understand what they see, such
> as
> yourself, will be invited to inspect the car and test the battery condition
> ... everything
> save exploring the device.
> 
> Doug L.

Doug,

That's a bit more intelligent talk, thank you for reply.
I'd like to see this device (whether it works as claimed or not),
but cannot attend your demonstration.

My immediate comments for your first paragraph:

> In essence we have a device that uses motion

To create that motion you spend energy. And to partially
harvest the motion energy you must first provide it.

If you use motion energy for something other than motion
(like generate electricity) you have less for motion, and
finally motion stops.

> to generate static electricity

I don't need details. Please provide your definition of
electricity. Also (separately) please provide your
definition and understanding of static electricity.

> that is
> then amplified

What is the source of energy for the amplifier?

> and converted 

What is the source of energy for converter?

> to useful electricity. period, end of story.

Sure sounds like it.

Victor